5 Mattress Stores in Columbus, Ohio

5 Mattress Stores in Columbus, Ohio

If you’re looking for mattress stores in Columbus, Ohio, this article is your ultimate guide. There are many mattress stores in the city, but we narrowed down the choices to just five. Plus, we’ve included an overview of what to expect from each store to help you weigh your options. 

Mattress Firm

Mattress Firm is one of the biggest mattress retailers in the United States, with more than 2,000 stores and locations across the country. There are six Mattress Firm stores in Columbus, Ohio alone. So, if you search “mattress stores near me” in the area, you’re guaranteed to find one without difficulty. 

The company offers a one-stop shop where customers can choose from a large selection of good-quality mattress brands, such as Nectar Sleep and Tempur-Pedic®, including Mattress Firm’s very own tulo and Sleepy. Aside from mattresses, customers can also find a range of bedding and bedroom furniture.

Mattress Firm Pros:

  • Mattress Firm offers a 120-night sleep trial to give customers a chance to adjust and find out whether the mattress is the right match or not
  • It is highly accessible due to the number of physical stores, plus an online store.
  • There is a wide selection of mattresses of different types and brands, with an extensive price range.
  • Products offered include bedding and bedroom furniture.

Things to Consider:

  • Lower price point mattresses means that many of the mattresses might be available for a better value at other stores or online. 

The Original Mattress Factory

The Original Mattress Factory remains among the homegrown mattress companies that still manufacture their own products. Currently, the company maintains 12 factories, which supply to more than 100 showrooms across the country. One of its stores is located in Columbus, Ohio.  

The mattresses and box springs that The Original Mattress Factory offers are built by hand in its local facilities and are sold directly through its stores. With a more traditional approach to making mattresses, OMF uses heavy-gauge springs, renewable cotton, and high-density foam to produce high-quality, comfortable mattresses. 

The Original Mattress Company Pros:

  • The selection of mattresses is uncomplicated and categorized into just four product lines, each category featuring straightforward qualities and benefits. 
  • By not having a middleman or retailer, the OMF can sell mattresses at a more accessible price range. 
  • OMF offers custom-size mattresses and caters to making mattresses for boats, RVs, antique bedframes, and hospital beds.

Things to Consider:

  • The product selection is relatively limited, so if you visit an OMF store, expect to find only mattresses under one brand. 
  • OMF does not have a lot of physical stores, but it does have an online store.


Tempur-Pedic was at the forefront when memory foam mattresses were still gaining a foothold in the industry. Now, it is a well-known name brand under Tempur Sealy International, a company that focuses on making and distributing viscoelastic foam mattresses and pillows. 

Most memory foam products sold by Tempur-Pedic have a base component called TEMPUR®, a material that NASA originally developed. This unique material contours around the body, relieving pressure and canceling motion. All these features are designed to help people sleep faster and longer. 

Aside from memory foam mattresses, Tempur-Pedic also offers hybrid mattresses, a combination of its proprietary memory foam and pocketed coil support systems. There is a Tempur-Pedic store in Columbus, Ohio, and you can also find its products from different retailers in the area. 

Tempur-Pedic Pros:

  • As a name brand, Tempur-Pedic assures the use of high-quality memory foam that delivers the promised comfort.   
  • Tempur-Pedic offers a wide selection of mattresses, also available in varying firmness. 

Things to Consider:

  • Tempur-Pedic mattresses start at a premium price range. 

Sleep Number

Sleep Number is best known for producing mattresses that can be controlled by smart technology. Sleep Number® and Responsive Air® are among all Sleep Number mattresses’ basic smart technology features. With these, people can adjust the firmness level whenever they want; at the same time, the mattress can respond to movements and automatically adjust its firmness on each side. 

The brand has four mattress lines, and the most luxurious so far is its Innovation Series, it has more modern features like temperature balancing and enhanced pressure relief. 

Sleep Number has 663 locations in the country, two of which are in Columbus, Ohio. Aside from smart mattresses, you can also find bedding, pillows, and upholstered beds. 

Sleep Number Pros:

  • Sleep Number offers many innovative features, like firmness adjustability, which may cater to your specific needs.
  • Mattresses come in a wide range of firmness and thickness options

Things to Consider:

  • Sleep Number mattresses are sold at a premium price point.

T.Y. Fine Furniture

T.Y. Fine Furniture is a boutique solid wood furniture maker based in Columbus, Ohio. While the company doesn’t manufacture its line of mattresses, it does carry a collection of high-quality organic mattresses from Naturepedic. Naturepedic mattresses are fortunately made locally in Chagrin Falls, Ohio, helping customers support two small local businesses with every purchase.

Naturepedic mattresses are certified organic and non-toxic and are built from materials such as organic latex, cotton, and wool, among others. There are also wool-free mattresses for vegan clients. Additionally, most Naturepedic mattresses can be customized for the ideal feel on each side, and parts can be interchanged at any time for your changing comfort needs. 

By not using flame retardants and polyurethane foam, Naturepedic promotes a more holistic lifestyle. The absence of potentially harmful materials encourages better sleep and helps protect the environment. 

T.Y. Fine Furniture Pros: 

  • T.Y. Fine Furniture has a physical store where you can visit to test the organic mattresses from Naturepedic. 
  • For quick and easy access, the company also has a strong online presence. 
  • To pair Naturepedic mattresses, T.Y. Fine Furniture offers a great selection of solid wood bed frames and other bedroom furniture. You can also find high-quality pieces from Stressless by Ekornes and American Leather. 

Things to Consider:

  • Organic Mattresses come at a slight price premium but remain competitively priced to Tempurpedic and Sleep Number. 

If you’re looking for high-quality furniture in Columbus, Ohio, check this article:

5 Best High-End Furniture Stores in Columbus, Ohio

More articles like this:

Leave a comment